Peppers in the Pot

One of my sister’s and my oldest memories of our grandmother’s cooking is her Pepper Pot soup. She would make huge vats of it and deliver it to our house along with loaves of home made bread. Although, she would sometimes vary her kitchen offerings with casseroles of pork chops and sauerkraut made with apples and caraway seeds, trays of lasagne (from a recipe she got from a Sicilian-American friend), home churned peach ice cream (in season), and “wet-bottom” shoofly pies made with sweet gooey molasses sandwiched between the crumble cake top and the flaky crust below. She simply loved to cook and feed the family. We lapped up everything, but our favourite was always that big pot of Pepper Pot soup.


We never understood why the soup was called Pepper Pot since there was no visible evidence of peppers – green, red, yellow, sweet or hot. But, with a little bit of Internet research, I had my answer. I discovered our version of Pepper Pot soup is one of two American regional soups with the same name. The one we were familiar with dated back to Colonial times and is known as Philadelphia Pepper Pot Soup. In my grandmother’s copy of Pennsylvania Dutch Cookbook of Fine Old Recipes (seen above), Philadelphia Pepper Pot Soup contained cayenne pepper as a seasoning – no doubt the origin of “pepper” in the title. The second tradition of Pepper Pot soup is a spicy specialty of Creole and Caribbean cooking and does contain visible peppers – green, red or even hot scotch bonnet.


Philadelphia Pepper Pot Soupa family variation
A traditional element in both the Philadelphia and Creole Pepper Pot is tripe. However, my grandmother substituted a cheaper cut of beef for the tripe and (of course) made her own rich brown stock. I vaguely remember my grandfather’s aversion to tripe, which probably explains the substitution. For this recipe, I’ve consulted her Pennsylvania Dutch cookbook and cudgelled my memory for her personal modifications to the soup. One obvious ingredient she added that did not appear in the original was tomato paste (or ketchup as a substitute!). My Pepper Pot uses her variation plus the homemade stock and noodles that are – in my opinion – what make the soup special.

The Stock
Make the stock at least a day before you make the soup. It is a two step process – first roasting and then a slow simmering.

  • 300 to 350g stewing beef
  • 1 large celery stalk
  • 1 large carrot
  • 1 large onion
  • 3 medium tomatoes
  • 2 cloves of garlic
  • 2 bay leaves
  • 1/4 teaspoon dried thyme
  • 1 teaspoon sea salt
  • freshly ground pepper
  • 3 litres of water (added after the roasting)

Preheat the oven to 200 degrees C (400 degrees F). Cut the meat into chunks, removing any large pieces of fat. Chop the celery, carrots and onion in small dice – known as mirepoix. Cut the tomatoes into quarters and mash the garlic with the side of a broad knife. Add all of these ingredients to a roasting pan, tuck in the bay leaves and sprinkle on the thyme, salt and pepper.


Roast for 30 to 40 minutes. Check and stir periodically to make sure the meat and vegetables do not burn. Remove when they are well browned. Scrape everything from the roasting pan, including the browned bits commonly known as fonds (but more accurately sucs) from the bottom of the pan, into a large stock pot. Deglaze the roasting pan with a little bit of the water. Add this and the rest of the 3 litres of the water to the stock pot. Bring to a boil, cover and turn down to a simmer. Simmer for approximately 5 hours. About half way through cooking, test for seasoning – add salt, if necessary. Since this is a slow cook, it is best to use a heat diffuser if you have one.

Strain the stock, reserving the meat and discarding the other solids. You should have approximately 2 to 2-1/2 litres of stock. Set some aside for making the noodles (see instructions below). Shred the beef and set this aside for the soup.

The Noodles
These should be made at least several hours before you assemble the soup so that they have a chance to part dry.

  • 200g (7oz.) of organic plain flour (unbleached all-purpose flour)
  • 1/4 teaspoon salt
  • 100ml stock (or less)

Put the flour and salt in a bowl, pour just enough cold stock (made the day before) to make a pliable dough ball. You probably will not need all 100ml, so start with a little and add more as required. Place the dough ball onto a floured board and knead for a few minutes until the dough is no longer sticky. Cover in clingfilm and let it sit for about 20 to 30 minutes.

Cut the dough in half. On a large floured board, roll out each half of dough to a thickness of 1 to 2mm – slightly thicker than pasta noodles. Cut with a sharp knife or a pizza cutter into 1cm wide strips and then into rough squares or rectangles. Set these aside on a lightly flour-dusted tea towel to slightly dry for a few hours. Turn over at least once during this time.


The Soup

  • 2 to 2-1/2 litres of stock
  • 2 medium waxy potatoes
  • 30g (1 oz.) tomato paste
  • 1 bay leaf
  • 1 teaspoon dried marjoram or 1 Tablespoon fresh marjoram
  • up to 1/4 teaspoon of cayenne pepper (see note in the instructions)
  • the shredded meat from stock making (see above)
  • the noodles (see above)

Put the stock in a large pot with the tomato paste and put on medium heat. While waiting for the stock to heat, peel and cut into dice the waxy potatoes. The dice should be same size as for a chowder. If using fresh marjoram, strip the leaves and finely chop.

Stir the stock to make sure the tomato paste has been incorporated, then add the potatoes, bay leaf, marjoram, and cayenne pepper. Be cautious with the cayenne as 1/4 teaspoon could be too hot for many – start with a pinch and then taste before adding more. Add the shredded beef. Bring to a boil, turn the heat down, cover and let cook for about 20 minutes so that the potatoes become soft.

Remove the lid and bring back to a gentle boil. Gently shake the excess flour off the noodles and slip these into the hot soup. It should take about 3 to 5 minutes for the noodles to cook. Ladle into bowls and serve with crusty rolls or bread.

* * *

It has been a long time since I had Pepper Pot soup, but this did strike a few cords with the memory of my grandmother’s soup. However, I think that next time I will add my bit to the family tradition by including more vegetables to the soup – perhaps carrots, peas or broad beans, and possibly even kale in addition to the potatoes – making it a more well-rounded meal and less “meat n’ potatoes”. The rich spicy stock and the comforting home made noodles, however, are definitely keepers.


    • Very Germanic style food from my Grandmother, but she was of an age that had friends who were first generation immigrants to the US – hence the lasagne, but she also had Lithuanian, Irish etc. friends, all of whom exchanged recipes. We were very fortunate recipients of such food! I read somewhere that Philly was (pre Civil War) predominantly German with some Quakers thrown in. My roots go back to both of those lines – German and Quaker – when the area was still known as Penn’s Woods. Rather chuffed to have finally answered that pepper question and pleased to find out that it is a Philly recipe!


  1. A beautiful memory and recipe. My mums aversion to tripe (due to a tripe in white sauce dish from her childhood) has ensured that I never tried it. The noodles look fantastic.


    • Well, I tried tripe ONCE and that was enough – rubber. So, no, not my cup of tea. However, friends who like it say that I just experience it badly cooked. Who knows…perhaps I’ll relent and try it again. But, in the meantime, I think I’ll stick to my Nan’s version of this soup!

      Liked by 1 person

  2. Thank you for sharing such wonderful memories of our Nan’s cooking. You started my day with very happy memories of smells and tastes I love. She definitely had a passion to cook for her family and an appreciation of cooking with fresh ingredients and simple combinations to make a wonderful meal or dessert. Something she taught to us. I would also add more vegetables to the recipe!

    Liked by 1 person

    • On the veggie front, we’re in agreement – an addition to the family tradition from our generation. Wow, the post really got me hankering for her peach ice cream. I know it is almost winter, but ice cream is an all-season’s dessert. Pity I don’t have Dad’s homegrown peaches!


  3. Great looking soup – though I’m aligned with you in thinking it would be still improved with veggies – that would be divine 🙂 What would you put in it?


    • Next time it will definitely have diced carrot, some peas, and kale or cavelo nero. I might even leave out the potatoes or at least reduce the amount. My husband suggested leeks (which I adore), but I’m thinking that because they are quite strong, they would change the flavour of the soup too much. I don’t want to detract from the rich spicy stock. And, of course, the noodles are a must!


  4. This looks delicious. What a wonderful soup your grandma made, with homemade ice cream and bread too? I seriously love all of your posts. I see you left the tripe out of your recipe. My grandma used to challenge me with tripe, tongue, chopped liver and all sorts of wonderful things that I ate happily until I asked what it was and realized that tongue was tongue and liver was liver and tripe was…….innards. Sometimes ignorance is bliss. Beautiful post. I love you homemade noodles.


  5. Sounds rich and delicious, but like you, I’d be adding a pile of veg for extra goodness. I have terrible childhood memories of tripe, they flood back each time I try to overcome my aversion. Tripe is in a definite no go zone for me!


    • I agree with you on tripe. My aversion was reinforced after watching one of the River Cottage TV programmes where Hugh Fearnley-Whittingstall demonstrated how tripe was made – straight from the cow. Yuck! However, as I’ve said in another comment, friends of mine (most of them Greek) tell me that tripe is very nice when cooked well. Though I may relent and try it again, the chances of me cooking it are 0%. Next batch of this soup will definitely be chock-a-block with veg.


  6. Here in Montreal the first snowflakes are arrived and it’s quite cold. I wish I could have your soup. Looks very good, and since is made from the memory of your Grandmother it seems even tastier!


  7. What a great, hearty soup! Our temps are going to take a dive in a few days and a bowl of this would sure be welcome. I like that your noodles are so thick, making it even more comforting. Unlike many here, I happen to enjoy tripe, though, luckily, I’ve never seen it made. I don’t think I ever will, either. 🙂


Comments are closed.